Slightly Squiffy Ramblings & Hex Hall Book Review (Coop de Book Review)

So I was pretty sick for the latter half of December, Gentle Reader. One of those dumb head colds that doesn’t do much but sap all your strength and leave you weak and floppy on the couch leaking mucus and complaining about death. Yeah yeah. I know, gross.

I was too dizzy to concentrate on anything. What I managed to write, is likely not very useful, but I did keep my word count up. I don’t have a choice. If I don’t finish RTW this month I’m doomed. DOOMED!

I read a bit, but tended to get frustrated easily. I even resorted to TV, which irritates me even when I’m not sick. Eventually, I tackled Hex Hall, because I wasn’t sure I’d be better by the end of the month.

Accordingly, I’m not entirely sure Hex Hall had a fair shot. Keeping in mind that I have very high standards for YA, and was hyped up on cold meds, crabby, stir crazy, coughing, and dizzy. Instead of your standard review here’s a sort of stream of consciousness tackling of that book…


Why did I pick this, again? Good cover. Well, OK. Here we go. Main chick seems nice and snarky. Not very unique but maybe I’ll get surprised.

Chapter 5

This book now reminds me of Harry Potter meets this old Live Journal fic blog I used to read, a decade or more ago now. What was it called? Monsters U, or something. (This was well before the Disney-animates-hair thing.) Anyway, dawn of the internet and all that. But I guess what I’m saying is, I’m not being wowed by originality. However, I like the casual breezy tone of the writing. At least it’s not too much work to read.

Chapter 8

OK, now not sure if I’m supposed to be amused or in suspense. I guess there is humor? But is it enough to detract from a predictable plot? All the characters seemed to be a bit eponymous high-school for me — the mean girls, the bad-boy crush, the teachers. It’s like an 80s-style teen movie but doesn’t push far enough into camp to be super-fab. I mean, I’ll take Sixteen Candles, or 10 Things I Hate About You, or even Mean Girls but if this edges into Teen Witch territory, I’m not sure I can keep reading.

Chapter 14

Oh dear. Now we are in a “main character is the chosen one” situation. Special. Prophecy. Dark father. Come on book, surprise me! Please?

Chapter 28

I have decided who the bad guy is. (The infiltrating eye or what have you.) Am having flash-backs to Chamber of Secrets, and I never even read it.


Bah. Probably because I kept associating it with aforementioned LJ Fic I knew what main character really was and so wasn’t ever surprised.


Not letting Twitter help pick the book group book again, unless it’s by an author I know I already enjoy.

Grumpy Gail is grumpy.

So endth this blog post.


…. And that rounds out the book group picks for the year. I’ll put the vote up soon for you to tell me which ones were your favorite. Until then, let me know if you have any thoughts on choices for next year. Hugs!



Romancing the Inventor

Romancing the Inventor: A Supernatural Society Novella

A steampunk lesbian romance featuring a maid bent on seducing a brilliant cross-dressing scientist who’s too brokenhearted to notice. Or is she?


Your Moment of Parasol . . .

1879 fashions carriage walking dresses via historicaltidbits blog

Your Infusion of Cute . . .

A cartoon showing a boy in a crinoline, 1858

Your Tisane of Smart . . .

Victorian Poverty Maps

Your Writerly Tinctures . . .  

Into the Writing Vortex with Jo March and Louisa May Alcott, 1869

Book News:

ace-artemis-fanartist- Portrait of Alexia Maccon.

Quote of the Day:

“The world is a stage, but the play is badly cast.”
~ Oscar Wilde

Questions about Gail’s steampunk world? There’s a wiki for that!
Share & Enjoy!


Posted by Gail Carriger

5 Responses

  1. Andrea Phillips said:

    Yeah, I was not impressed with hex hall either. And didn’t especially like the main character enough to get the next book.

  2. Richard Dengrove said:

    I don’t know about Hex Hall. However, isn’t creativity at least two old ideas combined with one another? How good the combo is is another matter.

  3. Nikki said:

    I read Hexhall on vacation a few years ago, ended up leaving it in the rental car. The cover was neat but the book was blah.

  4. Angelica R. Jackson said:

    I read Hex Hall some time ago, and it’s my favorite example to use in talks as a writer who drastically stepped up the game in book two. Book 1 was fairly predictable, with some funny parts, but not much more than the level of a beach read. But…book two is much more complex, with layers and twists. A much better read, imo

© 2022 Gail Carriger
Site built by Todd Jackson